Bathtub refinishing and tub liners are two popular options for renovating an old, worn-out bathtub without doing a full tear-out. But which is the better choice for your bathroom remodel – refinishing the existing tub or installing a tub liner? Here’s a detailed comparison of bathtub refinishing vs tub liners to help you decide.
What is Bathtub Refinishing?
Bathtub refinishing, also known as bathtub reglazing, involves applying a new coating over the existing bathtub surface. This resurfacing process provides a facelift for your old tub, making it look fresh and new again.
Here’s an overview of how bathtub refinishing works:
- The existing bathtub surface is thoroughly cleaned and sanded down to remove any old coating, soap scum, and grime.
- Any chips or cracks in the underlying tub material are repaired and filled.
- A new coating, typically an enamel or epoxy resin, is sprayed or brushed on to the tub surface.
- The coating cures and hardens, creating aglossy, protective finish over the old tub.
- A final detail cleaning and polish leaves you with a tub that looks bright, shiny, and like new.
Bathtub refinishing can restore the appearance of old fiberglass, acrylic, porcelain, and cast iron tubs. The process takes just a day or two and is substantially quicker and cheaper than replacing the entire tub.
What are Tub Liners?
A tub liner, also called a bathtub liner, is a molded plastic or acrylic sheet that is custom-fit to go over your existing bathtub. Liners come in one-piece and multi-piece options.
Here’s a quick rundown on how tub liners work:
- Precise measurements are taken of your tub and surrounding surfaces.
- A liner is custom fabricated to fit your tub’s shape and dimensions.
- On installation day, the old tub surface is thoroughly cleaned and prepped.
- Adhesive is applied to the back of the liner and it is lowered into place over the old tub.
- The liner adheres tightly to the old tub on all sides, with edges trimmed for a perfect custom fit.
- Silicon caulk is used to seal any edges and gaps.
- The finished product looks like a newly installed bathtub.
Tub liners are commonly made from materials like acrylic, ABS plastic, PVC, and fiberglass gelcoat. They are available in many colors and finishes.
Bathtub Refinishing vs. Tub Liners Comparison
Now that you know the basics of bathtub refinishing and tub liners, let’s dive into a detailed feature by feature comparison.
Cost
Bathtub refinishing is the clear winner when it comes to cost. Refinishing a standard tub starts at around $400-500 and goes up to $1000 or slightly more for larger tubs.
Tub liners have a significantly higher starting price point. The total costs for a tub liner installation, including labor and materials, ranges from $1000-2000 on average. Custom-shaped liners can cost $2500-5000+.
Winner: Bathtub refinishing
Installation Time
Refinishing can be completed in just 1-2 days. After surface preparation on day one, the new coating is applied and allowed to cure overnight.
Tub liners take 2-3 days for a typical installation. The first day is for measurement and fabrication, the second day for installation, and additional time may be needed for any adjustments.
Winner: Bathtub refinishing
Durability
The durability and lifespan of both options can vary based on materials and quality of installation.
Refinishing coatings usually last 5-10 years before needing to be redone. Porcelain and cast iron tubs that are properly prepped can last even longer.
Tub liners typically last 10-15 years or longer with proper care and maintenance. Materials like acrylic and ABS plastic provide excellent durability.
Winner: Tub liners
Appearance
Bathtub refinishing allows you to restore your existing tub while retaining its original look and style. The new coating will hide chips, scratches, and stains.
Tub liners give you the opportunity to drastically change the look of your bathroom. Liners come in a wide range of colors and even different materials like tile-look panels. You can pick a liner that matches your decor better than your old tub.
It comes down to whether you want to keep or change your tub’s look. For a seamless, subtle update, refinishing may be preferable. For a dramatic change, liners offer more options.
Winner: It’s a tie
Ease of Cleaning
The new refinished surface has the same ease of cleaning and maintenance as a new bathtub.
Tub liners also provide a slick, glossy finish that does not have grooves, chips or etched areas where dirt can collect. Both options are easy to keep clean with regular washing.
Winner: It’s a tie
Tub & Bathroom Size
Refinishing works for any standard sized tub since the resurfacing is done on the existing tub. Even older, cast iron clawfoot tubs can be refinished.
Liners have some size limitations. Small bathrooms may not provide enough access to properly lower a liner into place. Very large or uniquely shaped tubs also present installation challenges with liners.
Winner: Bathtub refinishing
Fitting with Surrounding Tiles & Fixtures
With refinishing, the exact same tub remains in place so the fit with surrounding tiles and fixtures is unchanged.
Tub liners alter the dimensions slightly since new material is being layered on top of the old tub. This can result in noticeable gaps between the liner and tiles or walls. High-quality professional installation minimizes such issues.
Winner: Bathtub refinishing
Flood Risk
With bathtub refinishing, the underlying tub material remains unchanged. Damage from a plumbing leak or flood requires completely redoing the refinishing job.
Tub liners add a water barrier layer over the existing tub. If a leak or flood damages the liner, only the liner needs replacement while the old tub may remain intact.
Winner: Tub liners
DIY Installation
Bathtub refinishing requires professional expertise. The refinishing products can be hazardous and the process is technically complex, especially for first-timers. DIY is not recommended.
Installing tub liners has become easier with new self-adhesive liner designs. With handyman skills, DIY installation is possible following the manufacturer’s instructions. Professional installation is still preferable.
Winner: Tub liners
Bathtub Refinishing vs. Tub Liner: Which is Better For Your Bathroom?
Bathtub refinishing and tub liners each have their pros and cons. Here are some key factors to consider when deciding which is the better choice for your bathroom:
- Budget – Refinishing costs considerably less than tub liners. If you are looking for an affordable facelift, refinishing likely makes more sense.
- Durability – Liners tend to last several years longer than refinishing before needing replacement. Choose liners for long-term durability.
- Appearance – To retain your original tub look, refinishing is preferable. For a wider range of color and style options, liners are better.
- Tub/Bathroom Size – For very small baths or oddly shaped tubs, refinishing is the easier option. Liners need more space for installation.
- DIY capabilities – Liners can potentially be DIY-installed but pro installation is best. Refinishing should always be left to the pros.
- Flood risk – In flood-prone homes, tub liners provide an added water barrier layer.
For quick, affordable renovations, bathtub refinishing is generally the better choice.
For durable, customized facelifts, especially in wet areas, tub liners tend to make more sense despite the higher cost.
Carefully weigh your specific needs and bathroom details before deciding between refinishing vs liners. And don’t hesitate to consult with bathroom remodeling contractors.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bathtub Refinishing vs. Liners
Is bathtub refinishing permanent?
Bathtub refinishing is not a permanent solution. The new coating applied over your old tub will last around 5-10 years before needing to be redone. With proper prep and application, refinishing can extend the life of your existing tub for years. But it will eventually require reapplication.
How long does bathtub refinishing last compared to liners?
The average lifespan of a bathtub refinishing job is 5-10 years. Tub liners generally last in the range of 10-15 years before requiring replacement. So liners do tend to last longer, but refinishing is still a cost effective way to get an extra decade from your old tub.
Can you put a liner over a refinished tub?
It is possible to install a tub liner over a previously refinished bathtub. But this is not recommended. The layer of existing coating can interfere with proper adhesive bonding of the liner. It is best to only install liners over the original underlying tub surface for optimal adhesion and performance.
Should I refinish or replace my cast iron tub?
For antique or vintage cast iron tubs in good structural condition, refinishing is likely the best option. Attempting to remove and replace an old heavy cast iron tub can damage the surrounding surfaces. Refinishing allows restoring the appearance while preserving a classic tub.
Is it cheaper to refinish or replace a fiberglass tub?
Refinishing a fiberglass tub costs around $400-$600 on average. Full fiberglass tub replacement averages $1000-$2000 including labor and materials. So refinishing can provide substantial cost savings over replacement in the case of a fiberglass tub.
Can you change a tub’s color when refinishing?
Yes, bathtub refinishing allows you to choose a new color for your tub. Standard refinishing coatings come in various color options from white to biscuit, bone, gray, and more. Custom color-matching for a precise color match is also an option.
Does bathtub refinishing require maintenance?
Refinished bathtubs do not require substantial maintenance. But avoiding harsh cleansers, abrasive scrubs, and rough treatment will help maximize the longevity of the refinished surface. Generally gentle cleaning with soap and water is ideal maintenance.
Consult With a Bathroom Remodeling Contractor
While this guide covers the key differences between bathtub refinishing and tub liners, you may have additional questions or unique bathroom considerations. Speaking with an experienced local bathroom contractor is highly recommended before deciding between your tub renovation options.
Reputable pros can provide further advice and evaluate your specific bathtub and bathroom to help determine if refinishing or a liner is the right choice. They can also give accurate quotes for your project budget planning.
Bathtub refinishing offers an affordable way to restore old tubs. For customized facelifts, liners bring more possibilities. Carefully compare the pros and cons for your needs. And don’t hesitate to call in the experts to ensure you get the best possible results from your tub’s makeover.